Did The Cowboys Miss Out? Analyzing The George Pickens Trade Fallout

Admin

3 min read

Post on May 07, 2025

4.0

Share

Did the Cowboys Miss Out? Analyzing the George Pickens Trade Fallout

The 2022 NFL Draft saw the Pittsburgh Steelers snag Georgia wide receiver George Pickens in the second round, a move that has many NFL analysts scratching their heads – especially those following the Dallas Cowboys. Did America's Team miss a golden opportunity to bolster their receiving corps? Let's delve into the fallout and analyze whether Dallas made a significant error by not pursuing Pickens.

Pickens' Potential: A Tempting Prospect

George Pickens possesses a rare blend of size, athleticism, and raw talent. Standing at 6'3" with exceptional leaping ability and a knack for contested catches, he immediately became a highlight reel waiting to happen. His college highlights showcase a fearless player who isn't afraid to go up and get the ball, a quality often coveted in the NFL. The potential for a game-changing receiver was undeniable, making his availability in the second round all the more intriguing.

The Cowboys' Receiving Room: A Need for Improvement?

While the Cowboys boast a talented receiving core featuring CeeDee Lamb and Michael Gallup, the question remains whether their depth is sufficient to compete for a Super Bowl. The team’s performance in crucial games last season highlighted the need for a reliable, big-bodied receiver capable of making those crucial contested catches in the red zone. Pickens fit that bill perfectly. His skillset would have complemented Lamb’s speed and Gallup's route-running expertise, creating a formidable trio.

Why the Cowboys Might Have Passed:

Several factors could explain Dallas's decision to bypass Pickens. Perhaps concerns about his injury history – he missed significant time with a torn ACL – played a role. The Cowboys' front office might have prioritized other positions or players they deemed higher value. Their draft strategy, focusing on immediate needs and perceived value, may have simply led them down a different path. Ultimately, only the Cowboys' decision-makers know the precise reasoning behind their draft choices.

The Steelers' Gamble Pays Off (So Far):

The Steelers, however, appear to have made a shrewd move. Pickens quickly showcased his potential, displaying impressive catches and becoming a key contributor to their offense. While it’s early in his career, his impact is already noticeable, potentially hinting at a future star. This further fuels the debate surrounding Dallas’s decision.

The Bottom Line: A Missed Opportunity?

The question of whether the Cowboys missed out on a key piece in Pickens remains a matter of debate among NFL experts and fans. While the team may have had valid reasons for their decision, the early success of Pickens in Pittsburgh undeniably makes this a compelling "what if" scenario. His explosive plays suggest a potential game-changer was available, and Dallas chose not to acquire him. Only time will tell if this decision will impact the Cowboys' long-term success. The 2023 season will be a crucial test, especially in close games where that extra receiver dimension can prove vital. Did the Cowboys miss out? The jury is still out. But the discussion will continue, especially amongst Cowboys Nation.