Do The Giants' Round 1 Picks Grade Out? Expert Opinions

Admin

3 min read

Post on Apr 25, 2025

4.2

Share

Do the Giants' Round 1 Picks Grade Out? Expert Opinions Divided

The New York Giants made waves during the 2023 NFL Draft, selecting cornerback Deonte Banks and tight end Darren Waller. But how do these first-round picks grade out according to the experts? Opinions are, predictably, divided, ranging from cautious optimism to outright skepticism. Let's delve into the expert analysis and assess the potential impact of these selections on the Giants' upcoming season.

Deonte Banks: A High-Risk, High-Reward Gamble?

The Giants' selection of cornerback Deonte Banks at pick #24 was met with a mixed reaction. While his athleticism is undeniable – he boasts impressive speed and agility – concerns remain about his experience and consistency at the collegiate level.

• Proponents highlight Banks' incredible physical tools, arguing that his raw talent and potential make him a worthwhile investment. His ability to cover deep threats and disrupt passing lanes is seen as crucial in today's NFL. Several analysts praise his upside and believe the Giants' coaching staff can mold him into a star.

• Critics, on the other hand, point to inconsistencies in his college play and question whether his skillset translates seamlessly to the NFL. Some worry about his tackling ability and his tendency to get beaten deep occasionally. The lack of extensive starting experience is also a significant factor in their reservations.

Darren Waller: A Proven Commodity or an Injury Risk?

The Giants' acquisition of tight end Darren Waller via trade, though not technically a Round 1 pick in this draft, carries similar weight in terms of expectation and impact. Waller is a proven talent with a history of impressive production, but his injury history raises concerns.

• The positives are clear: Waller offers a significant upgrade to the Giants' receiving corps. His size, athleticism, and route-running skills make him a mismatch for many linebackers and safeties. He's a reliable target for quarterback Daniel Jones, potentially boosting the team's offensive firepower significantly.

• The negatives center around his health. Waller has battled injuries throughout his career, raising questions about his durability and availability. His ability to stay on the field consistently will be critical to his and the Giants’ success.

Overall Grade: A Risky Investment with Potential for High Returns

The consensus among experts is that the Giants' Round 1 moves are high-risk, high-reward propositions. Both Banks and Waller possess undeniable talent, but their respective weaknesses and potential injury concerns cast shadows over the overall assessment.

The success of these picks hinges on several factors:

• Coaching and Development: The Giants' coaching staff's ability to hone Banks' skills and manage Waller's health will be pivotal.
• Team Chemistry: How well these players integrate into the team dynamic will influence their on-field performance.
• Injury Prevention: Maintaining both players' health throughout the season is paramount to their, and the team's, success.

Ultimately, only time will tell if these picks pay off. The Giants are banking on potential, taking calculated risks in an attempt to elevate their team to playoff contention. The 2023 season will be a crucial test of their drafting strategy and the development of these key players. The coming months will provide further insights into whether these choices prove to be shrewd moves or regrettable gambles.