Fantasy Baseball Dilemma: What To Do With Underperforming Closers Williams & Clase?

Admin

3 min read

Post on May 10, 2025

4.4

Share

Fantasy Baseball Dilemma: What to Do with Underperforming Closers Williams & Clase?

The fantasy baseball season is in full swing, and many managers are grappling with tough decisions. Two prominent names causing headaches are closers Emmanuel Clase of the Cleveland Guardians and Liam Hendriks of the Chicago White Sox. Both high-profile draft picks, their recent performances have left fantasy owners questioning their roster spots. Should you hold onto these volatile assets, hoping for a turnaround, or cut your losses and seek a more reliable option? Let's dive into this burning fantasy baseball dilemma.

Emmanuel Clase: A Guardians' Grip on the Closer Role?

Emmanuel Clase, often a top-three closer pick in drafts, hasn't lived up to expectations this year. While his velocity remains elite, his command and control have been inconsistent, leading to higher walk rates and more runs allowed than anticipated. His recent struggles have sparked speculation about his role within the Cleveland Guardians bullpen.

• The Case for Holding: Clase's pedigree remains undeniable. He possesses electric stuff, and a return to form is entirely possible. A change in approach, some minor adjustments, or even a short stint in AAA could revitalize his performance. Dropping him now could mean missing out on a potential resurgence.

• The Case for Dropping: However, the risk of clinging to a declining closer is significant. Fantasy baseball is about maximizing your chances of winning, and a consistently unreliable closer can severely hurt your team's chances. The Guardians' bullpen isn't short of options, so Clase's spot isn't guaranteed. Other waiver-wire options might offer a more stable path to saves.

Key Considerations: Closely monitor Clase's performance in his next few outings. Look for signs of improved command and consistency. News from the Cleveland Guardians regarding his role within the bullpen is also critical. If there are any hints of a demotion, it's time to make a move.

Liam Hendriks: A White Sox Comeback Story or a Lost Cause?

Liam Hendriks' situation is more complex, extending beyond simple performance. After his successful cancer treatment, his return to baseball has been met with both admiration and concern. While his heart is in the game, his performance this season hasn't mirrored his past successes.

• The Case for Holding (with Caution): Hendriks' story is inspiring, and his resilience deserves recognition. His experience and track record are invaluable. While his velocity might not be what it once was, his ability to pitch smart and get outs remains. Give him time to adjust and regain his rhythm.

• The Case for Dropping: However, his health remains a significant concern. His performance could fluctuate depending on his physical condition. Relying on him for consistent saves is a gamble, especially considering the numerous other viable closer options available.

Key Considerations: Monitor Hendriks' health updates closely. News reports and analysis from baseball experts focusing on his physical capabilities are essential. If there are persistent concerns about his health impacting his performance, it's a difficult but potentially necessary decision to move on.

Finding a Reliable Replacement

If you decide to move on from either Clase or Hendriks (or both!), don't panic. The waiver wire often presents opportunities. Look for closers in stable bullpen situations with consistent performance and low ERAs. Don’t be afraid to prioritize WHIP (walks and hits per inning pitched) and K/9 (strikeouts per nine innings) over save opportunities for increased stability.

Conclusion: Weigh the Risk vs. Reward

Ultimately, the decision of whether to hold onto underperforming closers like Emmanuel Clase and Liam Hendriks is a personal one. Carefully weigh the potential for a resurgence against the risk of a continued slump. Analyze their recent performances, monitor news related to their team situations, and consider the availability of suitable replacements. Remember, adapting your fantasy baseball strategy throughout the season is key to success. Good luck!