Lyon Loss Exposes Onana's Flaws: Matic Calls Out Man Utd's New Keeper

Admin

3 min read

Post on Apr 10, 2025

4.0

Share

Lyon Loss Exposes Onana's Flaws: Matic Calls Out Man Utd's New Keeper

Manchester United's disappointing 1-1 draw against Olympique Lyonnais in their pre-season friendly has sparked debate surrounding the performance of new goalkeeper Andre Onana. The game, which ultimately ended in a penalty shootout defeat for the Red Devils, highlighted some areas where the Cameroonian international needs improvement, with former United midfielder Nemanja Matic adding his voice to the growing concerns. The clash served as a harsh reality check, exposing potential vulnerabilities in United's carefully constructed defence.

<h3>Onana's Uncertain Start at Old Trafford</h3>

Onana's arrival at Old Trafford was met with considerable excitement. The highly-rated keeper, known for his exceptional distribution and composure on the ball, was seen as the ideal replacement for David de Gea. However, his performance against Lyon raised questions about his suitability for the Premier League's demanding physicality and pace. While his distribution was, as expected, impressive, his positioning and decision-making under pressure appeared less convincing. Several moments during the game saw him scrambling to recover from risky plays, leaving fans and pundits questioning his ability to command his area consistently. This inconsistency, particularly concerning his decision-making in one-on-one situations, suggests a need for adaptation and refinement.

<h3>Matic's Critique and the Need for Improvement</h3>

Adding fuel to the fire, former United stalwart Nemanja Matic offered a frank assessment of Onana's debut performance. Speaking on his podcast, Matic, known for his insightful commentary, didn't pull any punches, stating that "While his passing ability is fantastic, Onana needs to be more assertive in the box. The Premier League is a different beast, and he needs to adjust quickly." Matic’s comments echo the concerns of many observers who noted Onana's hesitancy in dealing with crosses and his occasionally erratic decision-making in goal.

<h3>Key Areas for Onana to Focus On</h3>

• Improved Positioning: Onana needs to refine his positioning within the six-yard box to ensure he is optimally placed to react quickly to shots and crosses.
• Enhanced Decision-Making: Faster, more decisive actions in one-on-one situations are crucial to minimize risks and maintain control.
• Adapting to Premier League Intensity: The physicality and speed of the Premier League demand a proactive and decisive approach, requiring Onana to adapt his game.
• Building Chemistry with the Defence: Solid communication and a strong understanding with the backline are vital for a successful defensive unit.

<h3>Looking Ahead: A Chance for Redemption</h3>

While the Lyon game exposed some weaknesses in Onana's game, it’s important to remember that this was a pre-season friendly. It provides valuable learning opportunities. There is ample time for Onana to integrate into the team, improve his understanding of his teammates, and refine his game before the Premier League season commences. The experience against Lyon should serve as a crucial lesson, pushing him to work on the highlighted areas and deliver on the immense potential he undoubtedly possesses. Ultimately, time will tell whether Onana can silence his critics and establish himself as Manchester United's long-term number one goalkeeper. The upcoming fixtures will be a crucial test of his adaptability and resilience.