Struggling Closers: Should You Drop Devin Williams Or Emmanuel Clase In Your Fantasy Baseball League?

Admin

3 min read

Post on May 10, 2025

4.3

Share

Struggling Closers: Drop Devin Williams or Emmanuel Clase in Your Fantasy Baseball League?

Fantasy baseball managers are facing a tough decision. Two previously dominant closers, Devin Williams and Emmanuel Clase, have recently experienced slumps, leaving many wondering if it's time to cut ties. This article dives deep into their performances, analyzes their potential for a rebound, and ultimately helps you decide whether to keep or drop these high-profile relievers from your fantasy roster.

The Case for Dropping Devin Williams:

Devin Williams, the Brewers' closer, was a fantasy darling early in the season. His electric changeup and dominant presence on the mound made him a top fantasy asset. However, a recent string of blown saves and increased ERA has raised concerns.

• Increased Walks: Williams' walk rate has significantly increased, a worrying sign for a pitcher who relies on precision. This suggests a potential loss of command, impacting his effectiveness.
• Decreased Velocity? While not definitively confirmed, some analysts have suggested a slight dip in his fastball velocity. Even a small decrease can impact a power pitcher's ability to overpower hitters.
• Injury Concerns: Although no official injury has been reported, a subtle decline in performance could hint at a nagging issue. Fantasy managers need to monitor news closely for any updates.

The Case for Keeping Devin Williams:

Despite the recent struggles, dropping Williams might be premature. His track record speaks for itself; he's proven to be an elite closer.

• Proven Track Record: His past performance showcases his capabilities and suggests this slump is temporary.
• High Ceiling: When he's on, Williams is one of the best closers in baseball, offering a high reward if he rediscovers his form.
• Team Support: The Brewers remain a strong team, providing consistent save opportunities.

The Case for Dropping Emmanuel Clase:

Emmanuel Clase, the Guardians' closer, has also shown vulnerability lately. While not as drastic as Williams' decline, his recent performances warrant a closer look.

• Increased Home Runs: A rise in home runs allowed indicates potential issues with pitch location or adjustments by opposing hitters.
• Consistency Concerns: Clase's once-reliable performance has become less consistent, leading to more stressful appearances and potentially blown saves.
• Team Performance: The Guardians' struggles could indirectly impact Clase's opportunities for saves. A struggling team translates to fewer high-leverage situations.

The Case for Keeping Emmanuel Clase:

Despite his recent struggles, Clase still possesses the tools to be a top fantasy closer.

• Elite Stuff: His fastball remains a devastating weapon, capable of overpowering hitters even on off days.
• Young Age: His relative youth suggests room for improvement and adjustment.
• Managerial Trust: Despite inconsistencies, the Guardians' manager continues to utilize him in high-pressure situations.

The Verdict:

The decision to drop either Williams or Clase is ultimately dependent on your specific league, roster needs, and risk tolerance.

• Drop Williams if: You need immediate help and your league has readily available replacement options offering more consistent performance. However, consider holding if you have space on your bench and believe in his potential rebound.
• Drop Clase if: His recent inconsistency is too much of a risk for your team, and you can find a more reliable closer in your league's waiver wire. But consider keeping him if you value his high ceiling and believe his struggles are temporary.

Ultimately, carefully weigh the risks and rewards before making a decision. Monitor their performances closely and consider consulting fantasy baseball experts or utilizing projection systems for further analysis. Good luck!