The Perfect Blend: Toronto FC And CF Montreal's All-Time XI

Admin

3 min read

Post on May 18, 2025

5.0

Share

The Perfect Blend: Toronto FC and CF Montreal's All-Time XI

The heated rivalry between Toronto FC and CF Montreal has captivated Canadian soccer fans for years. But what if we put aside the animosity for a moment and constructed an all-time XI combining the best players from both clubs? This dream team, a blend of talent and grit, would be a force to be reckoned with. We’ve delved deep into the history of both franchises to bring you the ultimate Canadian showdown, a team that truly represents the pinnacle of achievement in MLS.

Goalkeeper: Pat Onstad (CF Montreal)

Choosing a goalkeeper is always a tough task, but Pat Onstad's legendary career with CF Montreal makes him a clear frontrunner. His consistency, leadership, and crucial saves throughout his tenure solidify his place in this all-time XI. He was a wall between the posts and a true captain on the field.

Defense:

• Right Back: Justin Morrow (Toronto FC): Morrow's attacking prowess and defensive solidity made him a cornerstone of Toronto FC's success. His ability to contribute both offensively and defensively is invaluable in any lineup.
• Center Back: Laurent Ciman (CF Montreal): The imposing Belgian international brought a level of physicality and leadership to CF Montreal’s defense that few could match. His aerial prowess and ability to read the game were exceptional.
• Center Back: Chad Marshall (Toronto FC): A true MLS veteran and defensive stalwart, Marshall’s presence at the back was a calming influence for Toronto FC. His experience and commanding presence made him a key figure in their most successful periods.
• Left Back: Dwayne De Rosario (Toronto FC/CF Montreal): While primarily a midfielder, De Rosario's versatility allowed him to excel on the left flank for both clubs. His attacking flair and ability to deliver dangerous crosses make him a unique choice in this defensive position.

Midfield:

• Defensive Midfielder: Guillermo Barros Schelotto (Columbus Crew/Toronto FC): Although technically not a CF Montreal or Toronto FC player for his prime, his impact on Toronto FC was undeniable, so he's included here. His playmaking ability and leadership were pivotal to TFC's early success.
• Central Midfielder: Ignacio Piatti (CF Montreal): Piatti's electrifying performances for CF Montreal cemented his status as a club legend. His technical skills, goal-scoring ability, and playmaking were a constant threat to opposing teams. A true game-changer.
• Central Midfielder: Michael Bradley (Toronto FC): The captain and heart of Toronto FC for many years, Bradley's leadership and tactical awareness are irreplaceable. His contributions on and off the field are legendary for Toronto FC.
• Right Wing: Sebastian Giovinco (Toronto FC): “The Atomic Ant” needs no introduction. Giovinco’s mesmerizing skills, prolific goal-scoring, and unparalleled creativity redefined attacking play in MLS during his time with Toronto FC.

Attack:

• Striker: Thierry Henry (CF Montreal): The legendary Thierry Henry brought global recognition to CF Montreal. His experience, class, and clinical finishing made him a formidable presence in the attack. His presence alone elevates this team.
• Striker: Jozy Altidore (Toronto FC): Altidore's physicality, goal-scoring prowess, and ability to hold up play made him a crucial asset for Toronto FC. His impact on the club is significant.

Substitutes: The depth of talent from both clubs makes selecting substitutes incredibly difficult. Players like Blerim Dzemaili (CF Montreal), Kyle Bekker (Toronto FC), and Marky Delgado (Toronto FC) would all make strong contenders.

This all-time XI represents a potent blend of experience, talent, and legacy from both Toronto FC and CF Montreal. It's a testament to the rich history and competitive spirit that defines the rivalry between these two Canadian giants. Who would you include in your all-time XI? Let us know in the comments below!