Was Darrien Porter A Smart Pick? Grading The Raiders' 68th Overall Selection

Admin

3 min read

Post on Apr 26, 2025

4.3

Share

Was Darrien Porter a Smart Pick? Grading the Raiders' 68th Overall Selection

The Las Vegas Raiders surprised many with their selection of Darrien Porter, a safety from the University of South Dakota, in the third round (68th overall) of the 2024 NFL Draft. While some analysts lauded the pick as a shrewd move targeting a position of need, others questioned the value, given Porter's relatively unknown background. So, was this a smart pick? Let's delve into the Raiders' decision and grade their selection.

Porter's College Career: A Small-School Standout

Porter's collegiate career was far from the spotlight of Power Five conferences. Playing for the University of South Dakota Coyotes, a Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) program, he consistently impressed with his playmaking ability. His statistics speak volumes: He recorded numerous tackles, interceptions, and pass breakups, showcasing his versatility and instincts on the field. However, the jump from FCS to the NFL is significant, and many scouts questioned whether his performance would translate to the professional level.

Addressing a Raiders' Need: Safety Depth

The Raiders' decision to draft Porter can be viewed within the context of their existing roster. Their safety position, while featuring established players, lacked significant depth. Porter's selection addressed this vulnerability, adding a young, athletic player with the potential to develop into a valuable contributor. His ability to play both free and strong safety offers versatility, a trait highly valued by NFL coaches.

Strengths and Weaknesses: A Balanced Assessment

• Strengths: Porter's impressive athleticism, ball skills, and tackling ability are undeniable. His film highlights a player with a natural instinct for the ball and a willingness to make impactful plays. His size and speed are also assets in the modern NFL.
• Weaknesses: The biggest question mark surrounding Porter is the level of competition he faced in the FCS. The transition to the NFL, with its faster pace and more sophisticated offenses, represents a considerable challenge. He'll need to significantly improve his coverage skills against NFL-caliber receivers.

The Grade: A Risky, But Potentially Rewarding Pick

Grading the Raiders' selection of Darrien Porter is difficult. It's undeniably a high-risk, high-reward pick. While his talent is evident, the significant jump in competition level poses a substantial hurdle. His success hinges on his ability to adapt quickly and absorb the nuances of NFL gameplay.

Considering the context of the draft and the Raiders' needs, a B- grade seems appropriate. It's a grade that acknowledges the potential upside while recognizing the inherent risk associated with drafting a player from a less prominent college program.

The Future: Development and Opportunity

The Raiders' coaching staff will play a crucial role in Porter's development. Providing him with the necessary coaching, mentorship, and opportunities will determine whether this pick proves to be a stroke of genius or a missed opportunity. His progression throughout training camp and the preseason will be key factors in assessing the long-term impact of this selection.

Conclusion: Time Will Tell

Ultimately, only time will reveal whether the Raiders made a wise choice in selecting Darrien Porter. While the pick carries inherent risk, it also possesses significant upside. The potential payoff, given his skillset and the team's needs, makes it an interesting gamble, one that will be closely watched by Raiders fans and NFL analysts alike. The 2024 season will be crucial in determining the true value of this intriguing third-round selection.